The right tool for the job

One of the biggest open secrets about the Appalachian Trail is that you start the hike before you even get to the trail. This is true in a mental and emotional sense, given the enormous logistical task of dedicating four to seven months of your life to an attempt, not to mention the mountains of trail and gear research required to build a well-balanced team. It’s also true in the physical sense, because most northbound hikers (by far the most popular traditional direction of travel) begin their trip with the 8.8-mile AT Approach Trail, which begins a short hike from the base of Amicalola Falls, the tallest waterfall in the southeastern United States. This wisdom comes courtesy of “No Dog,” a podcasting shuttle driver (search “Shuttle Tales” on YouTube), trail angel, and backpacker with over 25 years of trail experience, who I was lucky enough to travel with when some fellow hikers were kind enough to let me share their transportation from Metro Atlanta to Amicalola.

There is a rough stone arch next to the visitor center at Amicalola Falls State Park that many hikers consider a mandatory landmark and the traditional starting point for hiking attempts. The arch, a short distance from the park rangers offering gear testing at the visitor center, is a natural place to make quick judgments about each hiker’s chances of success.

The vision test

Ask a hundred people what makes a successful hike and you’ll get a hundred different answers. Many will reference pack weight, previous experience, conditioning level, or “mental game,” shorthand for the inner strength needed to follow through with a hiking attempt even when trudging through cold rain and mud for days on end. Others still may refer to the “eye test,” which brings together many of these factors into a gut feeling about a hiker’s prospects. The vision test is inherently subjective and deserves to be analyzed as an example.

Two hikers stand together under the arch. The first hiker is thin and slender. Your backpack is clean, balanced and properly secured to ride well. They clearly pass the vision test. The second hiker requires closer inspection. A little softer around the midsection; his legs lack the definition that often develops after several months of prolonged effort on the trail. Your backpack may ride too low, putting undue stress on your shoulders. They may be carrying superfluous pieces of gear that will end up in a hiker’s box somewhere along the first hundred miles of the trail. The second hiker is clearly a novice, or close enough to it. Especially when juxtaposed, it becomes clear which of these two hikers would be credited with a greater chance of success. But then again, how do you define success in the AT?

Pass or fail

Hiking is perhaps the best of all endurance sports, if we consider it a sport. Although it lacks the pace of ultramarathons or other extreme endurance events, the magnitude of the undertaking sets it apart. Lihat juga tgvf. Unlike shorter events where speed is paramount and running is the point, hiking tends more toward a pass/fail paradigm. You either make it or you don’t. It is worth mentioning that there are fastest known time records and they are the exception to this rule. However, given that an increasingly smaller subset of the population could ever finish AT in less than 41 days, as Tara Dower did in 2024, we can leave out those exceptional individuals here. Given this framework, it is worth asking whether speed is the appropriate measure for such a company.

Match tools with tasks

Just as a ruler is not suitable for measuring waist circumference and tailor’s tape is insufficient for measuring the length of a room, it is important to adapt the tool to the task at hand. Few hikers fail to reach Katahdin simply because they hiked too slowly, meaning that average daily trail miles are not a reliable indicator of overall success. Especially when you factor in hikers who abandon the trail for reasons unrelated to hiking (family emergency, financial constraints, need to return to work), the overwhelming majority of hikers who abandon do so due to injury. Some suffer more obviously acute injuries, such as broken bones or gastrointestinal illnesses. Still, many more succumb to overuse injuries caused by the act of carrying twenty to forty pounds on their backs for hundreds of miles. These cases reveal how speed can become a surreptitious enemy. If the goal is to log miles without taking into account the body’s cues, whether driven by ego or lofty time goals, hikers can unknowingly undermine their chances of long-term success, especially early in the hike.

Here we return with our two hikers to the beginning of their trip. While the vision test would clearly assign higher odds of success to a hiker, it cannot take many factors into account. Maybe our first hiker feels great on the trail and starts logging 15-mile days all over again, only to fall victim to a series of potential injuries brought on by arrogance and exacerbated by a determination to hit a number at any cost. On the other hand, it is conceivable that the novice will run only very conservative mileage from the start, taking the time to get to know his pack and his body, and developing the humility necessary to adhere to short-term limitations in pursuit of long-term goals. That’s not to say that fit hikers will fail and fat hikers will succeed; Rather, the elements that make up a successful hiker are sometimes intangible. On a human level, we implicitly understand that appearances are deceiving and that people tend to surprise us and, sometimes, themselves. Breaking out of the inherently superficial nature of modern society and spending months on the road is a unique opportunity to challenge conventional wisdom and previous assumptions about what it takes to succeed. Anyone open-minded enough to consider hiking in the first place owes it to themselves and their companions on the trail to accept that success can look like many different things.

Slow, steady and towards Maine.

This website contains affiliate links, which means The Trek may receive a percentage of any products or services you purchase using links in articles or advertisements. The buyer pays the same price they would otherwise pay, and their purchase helps support The Trek’s ongoing goal of bringing you quality backpacking information and advice. Thank you for your support!

For more information, visit the About page of this site.